test

Centre for Sport Coaching

Improving international coach development and education systems

Research that has improved coach development systems and education provision internationally, and coaches’ practice in the UK.

Improving international coach development and education systems

The Challenge

Policy and programmes in sport coach education and development have been criticised for the absence of a coherent and consensual organising framework and a practice-based set of tools with which to support the development of sport coaches. This impacts on policymakers’ and practitioners’ ability to perform their work effectively as a result of inconsistent messages from coaching theorists, a lack of attention to important practical issues and problems with the relevance of the research agenda. The consequence has been a limited impact on the practice of education and development facilitators, and coaching practice itself.

RCfSC research has established the necessary underlying frameworks and researchers have gone on to apply these tools in a variety of settings, making a substantial impact on the policy and practice of coach education and development. The research underpinning this case study has been driven by a collaborative team of sport coaching academics, policy and programme developers, coach developers / educators and coaches.

The Approach

Critically challenging the definition of coaching

Our research has conceptually explored and empirically validated sport coaching as a goal-orientated, reasoning and decision-making activity, enacted through strategies, based on individual and other resources, embedded within and developed through complex social ecologies, using critical realist and cognitive meta-theoretical perspectives. This view of coaching has led to further conceptual research that views coach development and education as an exercise in enhancing individual and social resource to improve reasoning, decision-making and strategies – a view that has been empirically validated.

Modes of coach development and education delivery

Our work has shown how coaching experiences (often the principle source of coach learning) can be augmented and critically challenged by research models and tools. This has led to the development of two main modes of coach development and education delivery:

  • A more content-driven approach which uses research concepts to explore and unpack coaches’ experiences that is more focused and time efficient
  • A problem-based / needs-led approach which draws initially on coaches’ actions and experiences to highlight their reasoning and resources, with research concepts then used to underpin questioning frameworks, and thinking tools once problems / needs have been deconstructed. This approach is seen as being more relevant and motivating for coaches but may take more resources / time

Development and education tools

Our research has shown the benefit of supporting coach development and education through a number of specific tools:

  • Coaching is seen as broadly concerned with understanding the who (participants and coaches in context), what (sport and technical aspects of coaching) and how (pedagogical, planning and process skills)
  • Informed by the ‘who, what and how’, goals and curriculum (content, delivery) should be ‘constructively aligned’ – with research showing coaching performance improvements

Coach development and education evaluation

Our research has evaluated the impact of these frameworks and tools on coach development and education by utilising and applying innovative research philosophies and evaluation methodologies. In particular, we have uniquely drawn on a critical realist philosophy of science / social science and realist evaluation methodology, and tailored it to a sport coaching context [3, 4]. These adapted philosophies and methodologies have been piloted and tested in a number of sports and settings.

Interdisciplinary systems view

Our overall approach to research and evaluation emphasises how different layers of the sport coaching ecology (macro-social, institutional, group, individual and sub-individual) impact on coaching system, development and education activities – providing an embedded interdisciplinary systems view. Our philosophical / methodological ideas have also embraced the contingency and fallibility of the knowledge developed – which provides clear ideas about what knowledge is and how it can be used to inform development and education activities.

The Impact

Our research has transformed international thinking, policy and practice in the following areas:

Coach development and education design

LBU has a strong partnership with the International Council for Coaching Excellence (ICCE) and the European Coaching Council (ECC), which include representatives from the main international coaching stakeholders. After an open bidding process, the ICCE’s and ECC’s head offices were located at LBU. LBU staff (Abraham, Lara-Bercial, North and Petrovic amongst others) are centrally involved in the development of ICCE frameworks and resources. ICCE and ECC staff have drawn explicitly on LBU research to author / co-author the ICCE’s International Sport Coaching Framework, the International Quality in Coaching Model, the International Coach Developer Framework and the Standards for Higher Education Sport Coaching Bachelor Degrees.

Coach development and education delivery

LBU research has underpinned coach development and education programmes to sport coaching professionals in the UK. The English Football Association has made LBU’s ‘who, what, how’ development and education tool central to its coach education approach. The FA have commissioned LBU to develop and deliver a postgraduate diploma for 47 of their youth coach educators (plus others) over a three-year period. The youth coach educators’ work has impacted on the practices of coaches in professional club academies, and ultimately player experience across England.

Coach development and education system evaluation / review

Our research has provided good practice benchmarks, and evaluation and review methodologies that have made recommendations for, and had impact on, coach development and education activities across world- and European-level sporting organisations. For example, LBU conducted research for UEFA on its European-wide coach education framework, the Coaching Convention, which impacts 54 national country systems and on 1,000s of football coaches across Europe. This work has resulted in UEFA reviewing its provision for coach development activities, the further education of coaches and for coach educators.

  1. Centre staff were involved in a major evaluation of UEFA’s Coaching Convention, a European wide endorsement framework for national association higher level coaching qualifications in football including the Pro, A & B licences.

  2. Successful candidates include many high-profile football players and coaches. In 2014 Centre staff were only one of six university and research providers invited to bid from across Europe to undertake research on UEFA’s Coaching Convention.

  3. Having been successful in this bid and being awarded a grant of €110,000, research was undertaken that involved interviews with the UEFA expert Jira panel, other European experts in coaching and coach education and development, and all 54 of UEFA’s national associations. The research engaged with the very highest level of European coaching expertise in football.

  4. The aim of the research was to describe the current take-up of Coaching Convention qualifications across all 54 national associations, understand each national associations’ experiences, want and needs from the Convention, undertake a high level evaluation of the Convention, and make recommendations for its future improvement and evolution.

  5. The final report recommended that UEFA reinforce its work on reality-based learning, where coaches learn in situ rather than in the classroom, on further education and CPD, and on coach developers.

    Find out more on UEFA's website

Outputs and recognition

 

  • LBU staff members Duffy and Lara-Bercial were the lead authors of the International Sport Coaching Framework. Underpinning research support was provided by LBU staff member North:
  • LBU staff member Lara-Bercial was one of the main developers of the Quality in Coaching (QiC) tool
  • LBU staff members Duffy and Lara-Bercial were central contributors to the International Coach Developer Framework
  • LBU staff members Abraham and Lara-Bercial were authors of the international degree standards
  • LBU staff member Lara-Bercial and North were the lead authors of the European Coaching Framework (ECF). This is a European Commission funded project to the sum of £380,000. 
  • The iCoachKids website has been mainly developed and maintained by LBU staff member Lara-Bercial
  • North, J., Piggott, D., Lyle, J., Lara-Bercial, S., Muir, B., Petrovic, L., . . . Shaw, W. (2016). Research study on the UEFA Coaching Convention: A research report for UEFA. Leeds: Research Institute for Sport, Physical Activity and Leisure. Leeds Beckett University.  This was a UEFA funded project to the sum of £90,000. 

Contact Dr Andrew Abraham

Andrew is Head of Subject for Sport Coaching and Physical Education at Leeds Beckett University, where he leads a team of over 25 academic staff and oversees over 550 students. With more than 25 years in higher education, Andrew is a recognised leader in sport coaching, professional development, and academic governance. His research and practice focus on professional judgement and decision-making, coach development, and adult learning.

  • Sport, health and life sciences
  • Carnegie School of Sport
  • Research
  • Sport
  • Study With us

    Study for a research degree at Leeds Beckett and you'll join a thriving academic community in an inspiring and supportive environment. The Graduate School supports our increasingly active postgraduate research community and encourages students to make a difference to the university’s research culture and environment.

    The Graduate School
    Study With us
  • research with us

    Leeds Beckett University can conduct research on your behalf to help you to implement change and realise your business potential. Validating your ideas with academic evidence can be an essential part of winning contracts and fuelling business growth.

    Research for business
    research with us