Recent events in football have not cast a positive light on the treatment of women in football. After Jose Mourinho, the Chelsea FC manager publicly abused the club doctor for doing her job by going onto the pitch to treat a fallen player, the governing body, the Football Association, decided there was ‘no case to answer’. The decision of the FA was one taken without asking for the doctor’s account of events (Eva Carneiro, the doctor in question, has stated elsewhere that sexist and abusive language was used by the Chelsea manager).
When Heather Rabbatts (the first woman to be appointed as a director of The FA) spoke out in defence of the doctor it was decided that she should be investigated following complaints by two (male) members of the FA. Clearly this graduate, barrister, chief executive, Governor of the BBC and LSE, and Executive Chair of Millwall did not understand her role as token woman, albeit as head of the FA’s inclusion advisory board. The treatment of both women in this case is further and very overt evidence of what happens when patriarchy is tested. It seems that the offence committed by both Carneiro and Rabbatts is to challenge the male power that dominates the sport.
Recent research at Leeds Beckett demonstrates that the structural processes that regularly marginalise women from positions of power include informal appointment processes, ‘male’ centric organisational values, isolating and unsupported working conditions, lack of value and acceptance ascribed to women’s contribution to sport, and inaccessible development opportunities. Despite the FA’s best efforts this case is being publicly aired, more commonly these underlying processes are difficult to identify and consequently are hard for women to challenge.
More subtly there is the feeling of simply being out of place. In our research for Sport Wales on participation in sport amongst Black and minority ethnic groups[i] a Black woman, who is an active member of a local race equality forum commented that the lack of female participation in ‘formalised’ capacities gives the impression that women are not valued in certain sporting spaces. She explained how this can be disempowering:
“I really don’t know why there should be that gender difference in an age where so much equality is being talked about, and we feel that we have made so many advances as far as equality is concerned. But I feel inequality is still there, especially gender inequality, and as far as sport is concerned it’s still alive and kicking. I’m mostly the only black woman there [a BME sports forum]… the male domination of all these forums or bodies can be quite intimidating in the sense that you are coming into a situation where there is already an established group… Everybody looks at you and then you just think ‘I hope I’m not going to make a fool of myself here.”
This is just one out of many women who have voiced their experiences to researchers as one way of being heard and illustrating powerful male-dominated structures within sport. Inequality, like this participant describes, is still in evidence as the product and protector of patriarchy. Men currently enjoy safety in numbers within almost all governing bodies of sport. While the roots of modern sport lie in Victorian Britain, such experiences indicate the need for a more diverse and rebalanced face of football, and sport more generally, to make it a safe space for all.
[i] Long, J., Dashper, K., Fletcher and Ormerod, N. (2015) Understanding participation and non-participation in sport amongst Black and minority ethnic groups in Wales. Report to Sport Wales from the Institute for Sport, Physical Activity and Leisure. Cardiff: Sport Wales.
http://sport.wales/media/1647168/bme_sport_in_wales_-_final.pdf
http://eprints.leedsbeckett.ac.uk/1725/
Archive
-
2019
- January (5)
- February (1)
- April (2)
- May (1)
- June (1)
-
July (6)
- Women's football: Look how far we've come
- From France 2019 to 'Monday night footy'
- Demanding more from match analysis in the women's game
- Against the Run of Play: An Investigation into Women Footballers' Negotiation of Gender
- Thinking sociologically when comparing women's and men's football
- It’s not about flooding the market but building a pipeline: Improving gender diversity in football coaching workforces
-
2018
-
January (10)
- Ending weight stigma and discrimination in 2018
- Swedish death cleaning: how to declutter your home and life
- Where in the world!
- The importance of using a whole systems approach to obesity
- Obesogenic Environments: Does Proximity Matter?
- Public health policy and campaigns; health promotion, without the stigma
- Lack of funding for weight management services
- Importance of healthy nutrition in early childhood obesity prevention
- Will the lack of diversity in the events industry be addressed in 2018?
- Poor retention = restless, agitated students: Discuss.
- February (1)
- March (3)
- April (3)
- May (3)
- June (3)
-
July (9)
- FiFA World Cup (1) - Wimbledon (Love): Sport fandom in a crowded marketplace
- Three Lions roar: the mixed fortunes of England’s football anthems
- Sport may be an opium of the people but it matters
- Government’s LGBT Action plan
- The Childhood Obesity Plan: Chapter 2
- The NHS at 70 Years - Catherine Coates
- Sue Sherwin - the NHS at 70 Years
- National Writing Day: celebrating the power and pleasure of writing
- Breaking the Waves: Practice as Research in the Creative Arts
- August (3)
- September (3)
- October (6)
- November (2)
- December (1)
-
January (10)
-
2017
-
January (6)
- Can research students do participatory research?
- More than just a feel good factor? The relationships between sport and the arts
- Trump, inauguration and impeachment
- ‘Shared society’ and the ‘business case’
- How can befriending support people with a learning disability take part in leisure activities?
- New Year, New me
- February (3)
-
March (5)
- Social Science and the Emerging Strategies for Industry and Research
- ‘My tongue is the blast of a gun!’ On the Road with the Midnight Robbers
- Beyond targets and tick boxes: The challenge is set to create sustainable organisational change to support greater equality
- Why we need PR
- Politics and business: who is governing whom?
- April (1)
-
June (6)
- The contribution of green spaces to health and wellbeing
- National Writing Day: mapping the region’s stories
- Protecting parks for public health: why bother?
- Partnerships in Health and Well-being: A Focus on Leeds
- Changing role of CSR and Sustainability reporting in Supply Chain Organisations
- Brexit is an opportunity to revisit strategy for supply chains
- July (4)
- August (1)
- September (2)
- October (3)
- November (4)
-
December (7)
- What impact will Trump’s declaration of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel have?
- Five digital trends to look out for in Higher Education in 2018
- Is the party over? Local events and festivals in times of austerity
- What makes a terrible video game?
- Children's mental health a government priority for 2018
- What the Second World War can teach us about recycling in 2018
- Carnegie School of Education responds to Government Green Paper on children's mental health
-
January (6)
-
2016
- January (3)
- February (2)
- March (2)
- April (3)
- June (2)
- July (4)
- August (2)
- September (7)
- October (6)
-
November (9)
- Managing the England Football Team - A Permanently Poisoned Chalice
- Putting Leeds's goth scene into perspective
- Fake news
- Social Media: a new site for racism in football
- The John Lewis Christmas ad – a different approach for a depressing year?
- The US election and the New Politics of Inequality
- Historian explores the life of forgotten British antislavery orator buried in Leeds
- Celebrating 50 years of Landscape education
- The importance of online support forums for men experiencing infertility
- December (4)
-
2015
- January (6)
- February (3)
- March (3)
- April (3)
- May (2)
- June (4)
- July (2)
- September (3)
-
October (9)
- Assessing the impact of physical activity and food environment on obesity
- A Caribbean childhood: Sugar Cane Alley comes to Leeds
- Crunch lit: the future of finance
- Reflections of a poet: non-racialism versus racial inclusivism
- Environmental health consultancy service to prepare students for future practice
- Celebrating world mental health day with dignity in mind
- Marketing strategy for the year we live in - roadmap or survival kit?
- Improving health through education
- Serial winners - Leeds Beckett study gets to the bottom of why some coaches get to the top... and stay there
- November (4)
- December (2)
-
2014
- January (4)
- March (3)
- April (5)
-
June (9)
- Gender matters? Murray & Mauresmo prepare for Wimbledon defence
- From protests to England’s early exit, Brazil 2014. Has anyone even mentioned the health legacy of the World Cup?
- Le Grand Départ: A cycling legacy?
- Educating Dietetic support workers
- Dietitians in the Media Spotlight
- Jury still out on whether Eugene Goostman passed the Turing test
- Dietitians Week celebrates students' placement experiences
- Cycling, Bread and Circuses? Le Tour comes to Yorkshire
- In conversation with Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
-
July (7)
- Integration of Commonwealth Games key to its success
- Considering Media and Place
- Education strategies key as anti-doping testing results rise by 20% in 2013
- All Those Other Cyclists
- How will we use media during the Tour de France?
- Just who is responsible for Suárez?
- Education key to preventing doping in sport
- August (4)
- September (2)
- October (5)
- November (6)
- December (3)
-
2013
- January (2)
- April (3)
- May (2)
- June (5)
- July (3)
- August (1)
- September (7)
- October (2)
-
November (8)
- Analysing the role of stress in elite sport
- Blue sky thinking on Educating Yorkshire
- Children now slower runners than their parents
- Leeds Met to launch MSc Advanced Diabetes Educator course - the first of its kind in the UK
- Education and training for global health workforce planning
- How can sustainability help tourism businesses?
- Kenya under anti-doping microscope
- Arts funding favours London
- 2012
Categories
- Active Lifestyles
- Addiction
- Ageing
- Art
- Arts, The
- Austerity
- Autism
- Brexit
- Built Environment
- Business
- Centre for Culture and the Arts
- Creative Technology
- Culture
- Dietetics
- Digital
- Distance Learning
- Diversity
- Education
- Events Management
- Film
- Gender
- Health and Wellbeing
- History
- Leadership
- Literature
- Media
- Mental Health
- Music
- Obesity
- Performance
- Politics
- Retail
- Social Sciences
- Sport
- Sustainability
- Technology
- Tourism
- University